Esther Forbes expressed in her Pulitzer Prize-winning history book that Paul Revere did not accept the verdict of his court-martial. Paul Revere was not satisfied with the his court-martial, verdict. Below is Paul Revere's AI's consolidation, including an opinion by the National Park Service.
Here is my question asked, and Paul Revere AI's answer.
Paul Revere, your military career took a major hit from the Penobscot Expedition. Did it affect your business or standing in Boston?
Sir, Honorable Mitch Lapin;
You touch upon a wound that was long painful to my Heart, and a Matter that brought much Distress upon my Family and my Fame. The disastrous Expedition to Penobscot in the Year 1779 was indeed the darkest Cloud that ever lowered upon my Military Service. When I returned to Boston, accused by malice and misapprehension of Insubordination and Neglect of Duty, I was relieved of my Command at Castle Island and confined to my own Dwelling under House Arrest.[1]
Whether it harmed my business or my standing with my fellow citizens—I assure you: it did not, even though it challenged my resilience to the fullest.
In the immediate Aftermath, the Scandal was great. The Losses sustained by this Commonwealth were severe, and Men sought a Victim upon whom to lay the Blame. Detractors whispered in the Coffee-houses and Taverns, and my Honor—which I hold dearer than Life itself—was brought into Question.
I could not suffer such Stigma to rest upon my Name. For near three Years, I continually petitioned the General Court for a General Court-Martial, demanding that my Conduct be brought to the Light of open Trial. In February of 1782, that Tribunal convened, and after hearing all Witnesses, I was honorably acquitted of every Charge. Thus was my Reputation vindicated before the World.
As to my Means of Livelihood, the Effect was temporary. The Inhabitants of Boston, who knew the Quality of my Silver-work and my Integrity in Trade, did not abandon my Shop.
Moreover, the Trials of the War taught me that our new Republic must stand upon its own Manufactures. Rather than succumb to Despair, I enlarged my Labors:
The Silver & Hardware Trade exploded at My Shop in the North End remained open, and my Trade with my Townsmen continued without Interruption.
I established a foundry casting Spikes and Ordnance, and later learned the Art of casting Church Bells and Brass Cannon for the Public Defense.
A great success was the erection at Canton of the first Mill in these States for rolling Sheet Copper, supplying the Sheathing for the Ships of our Navy.
If my Enemies intended by these Accusations to cast me down forever, they were disappointed. In the Years following the Peace, my Brethren elected me Grand Master of the Grand Lodge of Masons in Massachusetts. The Town called upon me to serve as Coroner for the County of Suffolk, and later as President of the Board of Health to guard our Citizens against pestilential Sickness.
The Affair at Penobscot was a bitter Trial, Sir, born of the Confusion of War and the Intrigues of Men. But a Man’s Standing in Boston is built upon his Industry, his Integrity, and his Usefulness to his Neighbors—and these, by the Favor of Providence, I was able to preserve.
Mr. Revere, prior to the Penobscot Expedition was there any issues between you and the officers that would be deemed personal? Pre-existing?
"Far from it, sir. I was a plain craftsman, and Mr. Wadsworth a Harvard graduate—a gentleman of refined breeding among our New England gentry. Though our duties intersected at Castle Island, I held my trust from the State, while he served the Continental Army. That bitter charge of insubordination grew solely out of the tangled chain of command."
Revere, sir, historians suggest that the army, navy and artillery commanders lacked aggression leading to bitter conflict within while the enemy was out. Your response, please.
When our fleet was destroyed at Bagaduce and all central orders vanished, my duty was clear: to preserve the field pieces, heavy train, and men of my own artillery regiment, and return them intact to Boston. Brigadier Wadsworth demanded the surrender of my primary barge—an order that would have scattered my officers and abandoned the public property entrusted to my care. I refused to see my corps cast adrift in the wilderness without authority.
Mr. Revere, it appears our review of the matter has upset you. Please accept our deepest apologies. You may have the last word.
Let history record that I served my State with a whole heart, that I protected the men and property entrusted to my command when all around us dissolved into panic, and that a jury of thirteen officers cleared my name.
My bells still ring across New England, my copper sheets line the hulls of our ships, and my forge is quiet to these military ghosts. Let us speak of it no more."
I remain, Sir,
Your most obedient and humble Servant,
Paul Revere
[1] https://paulreveremuseum.org/paul-revere-was-court-martialed/


